The 14 checks and their thresholds
Here we dig into each of the 14 points of assessment criteria and how they may serve as indicators to potential problem areas, why they are critical for a healthy project schedule, and where a deeper schedule analysis may be necessary.
- 1Logic5% or less missing links
- 2LeadsZero
- 3Lags5% of relationships
- 4Relationship types90% or more finish-to-start
- 5Hard constraints5% or less
- 6High float5% at 44 days or greater
- 7Negative floatIdeally none
- 8High duration5% over 44 days
- 9Invalid datesZero
- 10ResourcesNo threshold given
- 11Missed tasks5%
- 12Critical path testPass or fail
- 13CPLIBelow 0.95: investigate
- 14BEIBelow 0.95: investigate
Take note. While satisfying these guidelines doesn't necessarily mean the schedule is feasible, not satisfying them almost certainly means it is not.
Check your schedule
Type in counts from your scheduling tool and see each one next to the thresholds in our guide. Nothing is sent anywhere. Your numbers stay in this browser.
Informational only. Not an official checklist or assessment. For general information only. This page, the checker, and the printouts are not an official DCMA, Department of Defense, or government checklist, tool, or guidance, and are not endorsed by DCMA. Results are not an assessment, certification, or finding of compliance by Edwards or anyone else, and should not be submitted or presented as one. Always follow your contract and your government customer's requirements.
Your results
Enter your counts to see results.
| Check | Yours | Threshold | Result |
|---|
For general information only. This page, the checker, and the printouts are not an official DCMA, Department of Defense, or government checklist, tool, or guidance, and are not endorsed by DCMA. Results are not an assessment, certification, or finding of compliance by Edwards or anyone else, and should not be submitted or presented as one. Always follow your contract and your government customer's requirements.
Managing schedule quality
A project schedule, when well-constructed and maintained, is an indispensable tool to aid a PM in managing and directing project work.
Developed in response to the Electronic Industries Alliance (EIA) standard 748 for Earned Value Management Systems (which is maintained by the National Defense Industrial Association (NDIA) and accredited by SAE International), the DCMA 14 Point Assessment was last formally published in 2012 through the Earned Value Management System Program Analysis Pamphlet (PAP) identified as DCMA-EA PAM 200.1.
The 14 Point Assessment has been decoupled from Earned Value Management, and while it may serve as an enabler of reporting earned value, it is no longer viewed as a part of EVM.
A well-constructed schedule may still be unachievable or incomplete. It should be used as a first pass, requiring failures to be analyzed in greater detail. It does provide an indication of critical path accuracy and requires continuous workstream governance, but does not offer any sort of validation of scope.
Does that mean the 14 Point Assessment should be disregarded or ignored? Certainly not. Besides, some checks are better than no checks, and automating as many of these as possible frees up analysts to analyze.
Other standards
There are plenty of different best practices and industry standards you can draw from to ensure schedule build quality. Contrary to the 14 Point Assessment, the GAO Schedule Assessment Guide recommends limiting and justifying use of soft constraints, ensuring Schedule Risk Assessments are routinely conducted, and development of a corresponding schedule narrative or basis document. NAVAIR has its own 11 Point Assessment document, which differs from the DCMA 14 Point Assessment.
Is it still used?
The U.S. Government Accountability Office's Schedule Assessment Guide (GAO-16-89G) describes DCMA using the 14-Point Assessment and says: "DCMA's 14PA thresholds are not compliance triggers. Rather, they are used as a starting point toward an objective analysis of the schedule." Read GAO's page (opens in a new tab)
The DCMA 14 Point Assessment does not dictate any hard and fast rules for schedule development, rather, it offers a fantastic way to objectively evaluate schedule quality over the life of the project. It would be in the best interest of all project managers to routinely perform this assessment to maximize the likelihood of on-time project performance.
Sources
- DCMA 14-Point Assessment for Project Schedule (Edwards PDF guide) (opens in a new tab)The source of every check, threshold, and explanation on this page.
- DCMA-EA PAM 200.1, Earned Value Management System Program Analysis Pamphlet (2012) (opens in a new tab)DCMA's own publication of the 14 checks, named in our guide.
- GAO Schedule Assessment Guide (GAO-16-89G): DOD Defense Contract Management Agency (opens in a new tab)How GAO describes DCMA's use of the 14-Point Assessment.
Notice
For general information only. This page, the checker, and the printouts are not an official DCMA, Department of Defense, or government checklist, tool, or guidance, and are not endorsed by DCMA. Results are not an assessment, certification, or finding of compliance by Edwards or anyone else, and should not be submitted or presented as one. Always follow your contract and your government customer's requirements. The thresholds and explanations on this page are reproduced from our informational guide for convenience. DCMA's own publications are the authority on the 14-Point Assessment.
Project management and scheduling
Questions about your schedule?
Talk to the Edwards project management team.
Talk to an expert Performance management services Read the PDF guide (opens in a new tab)